Thread:MrBlonde267/@comment-24845073-20140902064201/@comment-265341-20140902090723

We've argued about it a lot. The problem with "it's a different version of the character" is that DC tends to be a continuity smoothie. They don't make a clean break and start over completely fresh. They pick and choose what they like from history. So there are plenty of Pre-Crisis stories that remain canon in Post-Crisis continuity.