Thread:Alchemist91/@comment-1038387-20150202205752/@comment-1038387-20150202213118

Nope. It's not our call to make how significant it is. We can only deal in absolutes. He was shown as both.

He's been explicitly linked to both. He was Christian in The Chalice and IIRC Heaven's Ladder, and non-believing, lapsed and/or atheist in Year Two, and Gods of Gotham.