User blog comment:Gcheung28/Batman vs. Superman/@comment-5898911-20130205013622

As much as I love Batman (honestly, I do, he's my all time favorite_, he really can't beat Superman, even with prep. In fact, he NEVER has, even in non-canon incidents. Hush- Ended when Superman broke free of the mind control, and Batman nearly shattered his hand while punching Superman with a Kryptonite Ring. Tower of Babel- Batman had months of prep, and he used a chunk of Red Kryptonite. However, Superman overcame the excruciating pain, as seen later in the comic. The Dark Knight Returns- Batman had prep, and a power suit, but he never actually won. They were facing each other pretty evenly (and this was a weak Superman in comparison with the mainstream one), and it ended with Batman faking a heart attack. So every major fight between them has ended unfinished, and Batman never had the advantage.