Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27766744-20160501182742/@comment-27766744-20160514063602

I agree to disagree... I understand your point, and I agree to have different profiles for this kind of cases is absurd... But I disagree with the part that there is no evidence than they are not the same person... I confess I don't know this Congo Bill Character, but DC was very explicit in 52 and history of the dc universe that the only people who survived the first crisis were: Power Girl, Donna Troy (in a very strange way), Superman-prime, Superman and Lois Earth-2 and Luthor Earth-3... By saying that, it is implied that anybody else is a different person... Could they have the same past? YES, but still they are different people... Because if for example Earth-2 was to be revived (and I am not talking about what happen in Infinite Crisis Earth 2 that was a copy), there would be two of that character... So yes, DC indirectly said that any character from Earth 2 (except the 3 mentioned) are different people than the ones in New Earth