Thread:Byfield/@comment-1387629-20130622133651/@comment-220364-20130622143624

re: Origin - Since the template page still implies that "Origin" will auto-cat based on various terms, and that function has been removed, the documentation shouldn't be there. It implies the template will do some thing it won't.

re: Quotes

Yes, I have been adding the /Quote categories to character pages manually when the page quote is sourced to the topic. But I haven't been using QuoteWithCat, I've been adding a category link.

Reason being, the character template will, without fail, add a /Quote category if "Speaker" points to something other than the article. (2 examples: Jack Ryder (Justice) had just "Jack Ryder" generating Category:Jack Ryder/Quote and Iris West (Justice) had "Iris West, after the Flash ends another date prematurely." creating the really odd Category:Iris West, after the Flash ends another date prematurely./Quote)

For me, if the template is going to categorize the quotes for other "Speakers", it should be doing it if the speaker is the page topic. If it cannot for coding reasons (my assumption here), then the category should be added.

If the intent is that the /Quote categories should only have page quotes from pages on the issues, then the other infoboxes should be revisited to remove the auto-catting to /Quote.

As far as I can tell, I've only seen the odd case where adding the category manually results in "" showing up on the /Quote page (and I wish I could remember the last one to give an example). In the rest of the cases the quote from the article does get copied fully to the /Quote page.