Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27766744-20180419193905

There is something I don't understand about how this wikia use different earthes in characters version...

At first I asked why it doesn't diferentiate Earth-One/Earth-Two from New Earth (pre crisis/post crisis), and you told me it was because both Earth "became" New Earth... so we say for example that Allan Scott from Earth Two is the same Allan Scott from New Earth "transformed" by the crisis...

Ok, I buy that... But then why do we separate New Earth from Prime Earth if it is the same case? New Earth BECAME Prime Earth because of Flashpoint / Manhattan... So they should be treated as the same...

Of course we can say, "but in divergence there were characters from New Earth", yes, and also from Earth Two and One!

I really don't understand why we say Earth One/Earth Two (and not in ALL CASES) are the same characters as New Earth, but we say that Prime Earth characters are not New Earth characters...

I am not talking about if they are or not the same character, but to use the same criteria in both escenarios... 