Talk:Superman Vol 1 309

Nightwing Overview
Under Confessions of a Superman fan a person using the moniker "Nightwing" wrote an overview of this storyline: http://www.superman.nu/nightwing/nightwing/adventures/when_superman_was_a_mutant.htm

As Nightwing points out there was a lot more wrong with Supergirl's story then what Superman stated:

"Superman would have to accept that every time-traveling journey to Krypton of the past, every visit to Kandor, every battle with the Phantom Zone villains was the product of his imagination. And if he does accept that, then logically his reaction wouldn't be, "oh well, guess I'll get serious with Lois," it would be, "My God, I'm a raving lunatic! I need to get off the planet before someone gets killed!" Not that there would be any reason to believe it, mind you; a quick trip to the Daily Planet files would confirm his past battles with the Phantom Zone villains, or even better he could just say, "Hey, Jimmy; am I crazy or didn't you visit Kandor a few times with me?'"

That was a common problem with Silver Age stores that did things like this-the continuity made them nonsensical in the extreme.--BruceGrubb (talk) 13:48, November 6, 2016 (UTC)