Thread:Tupka217/@comment-3361105-20130704164420/@comment-3361105-20130704165918

That first one is the textless version of the cover. You can see by the logo's placement on the real cover.

I say the second one should be replaced, too. The character is prominent in it. I'm of the opinion that we shouldn't be chopping up covers or textless covers for the sake of making a character who is already prominent in it slightly more prominent.

As far as silver or golden age characters - I'd rather pretend that they are CSPs, if only to avoid the work of making a category and writing licensing code that is essentially just going to end up being a shortcut to having people crop modern age covers needlessly.

If the full textless cover for an image doesn't suit the needs of a character image, that doesn't matter. It suits our needs elsewhere, killing two birds with one stone. There is absolutely no reason to have a crop of a cover we already have a textless version of.