Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-20551-20181015063237/@comment-20551-20181017041835

Shadzane wrote: Your objection to Only only really applies to new comics.. There's nothing stopping Grant Morrison from plopping Earth-One Roberta into some comic. In fact, since I mentioned it, that basically ensures that he will. But even then, there is this overhead which is just needless. This came up from a literal example: Lenny is a character in ; his first appearance went from "only" to "1st" once he reappeared later, only to be killed. There's no reason to even mark this.

SforHope wrote: If they don't have a 2nd or 3rd, they definitely don't need a 1st. We don't tag or. If someone appears one time, that *is* his first appearance; nothing is misleading about that.