Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27766744-20160501182742/@comment-918732-20160501230303

So if a character is in a different continuity, but his or her profile is similar enough to have only one profile page, the character is to be identified as the same character even when they are from different Earthes?

Only in this specific circumstance:

If the character is from Earth-One or Earth-Two or Earth-Four or Earth-S** or Earth-X**, and ended up on New Earth. This is because of the unique circumstances of how New Earth was created when Earth-One, Earth-Two, Earth-Four, Earth-S and Earth-X were mashed together in Crisis on Infinite Earths***


 * I don't think there are any examples of Earth-S/New Earth combined pages, because every character was significantly changed post-crisis.


 * I don't think there are any examples of Earth-X/New Earth combined pages, because there aren't many significant characters native to Earth-X.


 * Well, there are some Earth-Twelve/New Earth combined pages, but I don't think they should exist, and I've been meaning to say something about it.