Board Thread:Policies/@comment-246292-20140502145126/@comment-220364-20140504222732

MrBlonde267 wrote: Admin ruling: We're not listing anybody as Earth-10 if they haven't been explicitly seen on Earth-10. That's conjecture.

I personally think it would be better to have one Pre-Crisis article for these characters instead of multiple separate Pre-Crisis articles. I think it would serve the data better to have any differences explained either in-universe or in the "Notes" section of the page. This is not unprecedented.

RE Earth-10: Got it and agreed. (And I'm not sure if WAG has been defined before or not. It's a Wild Ass Guess... so conjecture but more so.)

As for multiple versions in one article. I'm nor adverse to it, it's just:
 * 1) Structuring the history and notes section. Actually pulling apart the history of the characters and accepting that some of the sections being partially or full in a real world context.
 * 2) Having a stylistic/admin directive as to which reality to use as the dab.
 * 3) Being sure it's OK to lose some category links. If we keep the separate pre-Crisis pages as redirects (a good idea I think to keep the appearances, images, and quotes, if any, straight) they won't be readily accessible from the page without a custom section.
 * 4) Getting some direction on which pieces from which versions to put into the infobox.