- So, residents of Earth-38, Earth-1 and Earth-BL/73/whatever now believe they've always been the same Earth, and only the Paragons know different? That sounds like how we're dealing with Dakotaverse.
- I'm not sure if we should differentiate between Arrowverse: Earth-1 and Arrowverse: Earth-Prime. While it is accurate, it's a SEO and UX nightmare for people like Weather Witch or JJ Diggle. I think it makes more sense to let them keep (Arrow) (or make it Arrowverse), with a multicont note.
- I vote against moving all the other series and movies to (Arrowverse: Earth-Whatever). Since it didn't create a single Universe but a new Multiverse, it'd make more sense to just call them by their series name - while (Arrowverse: Earth-9) will be the same pre and post-COIE, (Arrowverse Earth-2) is not (Stargirl TV Series). Same for Earth-19.
- Old series... still open on whether we should treat Earth-66, 89 et al as separate from their original series, see the Joker alive discussion.
- Did they use actual footage from the GL movie for Earth-12? The esthetic looked the same, but it's been a while since I saw that.
- Looks like we're going to have to split Titans and DP.
130,661
pages
ALL POSTSArrow and Crisis on Infinite Earths
<p>After Crisis, here are a couple of questions, suggestions, and assorted thoughts.
</p>
(Edited by Tupka217)
0
<p>Does Jason ever appear? If he's mentioned only, he doesn't need a link.
</p>
(Edited by Tupka217)
0
<p>He was only ever mentioned once by his first name, "He looks just like my son, Jason."
</p>
(Edited by 1137a)
0
That does not need a page.
(Edited by Tupka217)
0
Are there any major contradictions that can affect history?
(Edited by Nalka123)
0
<div class="quote"><i>
<p>Tupka217 wrote:
That does not need a page.
</p>
</i></div>
<p>Removed all links. </p>
<p>Removed all links. </p>
(Edited by 1137a)
<div class="quote"><i>
<p>SeanWheeler wrote:
So would new characters showing up in National City in new episodes of Supergirl be under Arrowverse or Arrow: Earth-38? Like if Kara Danvers were to fight Volcana, who has never been in the Arrowverse before in any capacity, would her page be created as Claire Selton (Arrowverse) or Claire Selton (Arrow: Earth-38)?
</p>
</i></div>
<div class="quote"><i> <p>Tupka217 wrote: Arrowverse. </p> </i></div>
<p>Sine we’re not doing this for Gravedigger, are we only doing it for Supergirl characters then? Are we not doing it for characters we figure don’t come from Earth-1 and we aren’t doing integration? I’m no longer sure what the consensus was. </p>
<div class="quote"><i> <p>Tupka217 wrote: Arrowverse. </p> </i></div>
<p>Sine we’re not doing this for Gravedigger, are we only doing it for Supergirl characters then? Are we not doing it for characters we figure don’t come from Earth-1 and we aren’t doing integration? I’m no longer sure what the consensus was. </p>
(Edited by MysteryScooby)
Looks like Gravedigger was marked with a move template.
(Edited by SeanWheeler)
It's been reverted.
(Edited by MysteryScooby)
0
<div class="quote"><i>
<p>MysteryScooby wrote:
</p>
<div class="quote">
<p>SeanWheeler wrote:
So would new characters showing up in National City in new episodes of Supergirl be under Arrowverse or Arrow: Earth-38? Like if Kara Danvers were to fight Volcana, who has never been in the Arrowverse before in any capacity, would her page be created as Claire Selton (Arrowverse) or Claire Selton (Arrow: Earth-38)?
</p>
</i></div>
<div class="quote"><i> <p>Tupka217 wrote: Arrowverse. </p> </i></div>
<p>Sine we’re not doing this for Gravedigger, are we only doing it for Supergirl characters then? Are we not doing it for characters we figure don’t come from Earth-1 and we aren’t doing integration? I’m no longer sure what the consensus was. </p> </div> <p>Honestly, I had forgotten I had said that. I think that would just add to the confusion if two different universe designations are used. </p>
<div class="quote"><i> <p>Tupka217 wrote: Arrowverse. </p> </i></div>
<p>Sine we’re not doing this for Gravedigger, are we only doing it for Supergirl characters then? Are we not doing it for characters we figure don’t come from Earth-1 and we aren’t doing integration? I’m no longer sure what the consensus was. </p> </div> <p>Honestly, I had forgotten I had said that. I think that would just add to the confusion if two different universe designations are used. </p>
(Edited by Tupka217)
<p>Looking at some articles. One editor created a Kal-El (Arrowverse: Earth-96) article, that another editor tagged for merging with Kal-El (Superman Returns) (that still have the Crisis section).
</p><p>Then there are some character articles (ex. Helena Kyle (Birds of Prey)), where they're listed as having died in the Crisis crossover, while other character articles don't.
</p><p>My personal favorite is Batwoman (TV Series) Episode: Crisis on Infinite Earths: Part Two. It has links for Kal-El (Arrowverse: Earth-96) and Kal-El (Arrowverse: Earth-167). However, the other Earth-96 and Earth-167 links goes to the <i>Superman Returns</i> and <i>Smallville</i> character articles.
</p><p>We really need to do something about this, before we end up with a massive(r) mess.
</p>
(Edited by KylieMfever)