169 Votes in Poll
I've read it, yeah.
In which one do I rule over the Earth with my army of robots and my intellect, finally sending Batman to his doom in one of my trials?
Earth-R. Sadly, no writer has chosen to chronicle this in a comic, nor do we cover it on the wiki. There was Gotham City's Zero Year on Prime Earth, where you came close, though. Tell me, Riddler, how's Ed doing in there?
He didn't want me to take over, as usual, but I was able to anyway.
Sweet. Tell him and Oswald hi for me, if you see them.
New earth should be higher
There is not "should be" here.
New Earth is not higher for the same reason that Earth-One and Earth-Two have not gotten more votes: newer fans are almost exclusively focused on what is right now on the shelves, and few of them decide to delve into their fandom's history. Even fewer of them end up liking the older stuff better than the newest, "shinier" stuff.
It sucks if you think your favorite era is being undervalued and even belittled -I do-, but that is how things are. Complaining about "deservingness" is pointless, and online polls are often meaningless anyway.
They're not meaningless if they lead to interesting discussions like this
What do you think?