Kelly’s second suit is good but the stupid looking helmet ruins it.

Like why is it so big?

Kelly's final suit looks really good, it's the most comic accurate Guardian suit so far, even if it isn't perfect.

Helmets are really hard to get right IRL.

Earth-X's american flag pattern is a little rough so it's a close second. Though the best one is still Kelly's Guardian suit. The gold helmet was far more solid looking than the silver. The iconic blue and gold combination is a classic, and the beads were an Ethiopian style the actress chimed in with for a personal touch.

I like that the gold on the earth-x suit looks less plasticy.

Not going to lie I like Kelly’s suit better the first one the second looks like doctor fate and I don’t like it

The second one looks like Guardian. It's the only one that even remotely resembles the comics costume.

Kelly's does as well really. With the more accurate helm.

None of the above.