It’s between 89 Batman and Superman: The Movie

Which Superman we talking here?

Superman: The Movie, which isn't even my favorite Superman movie. Superman 2025 holds that honor.

I prefer S:TM myself, but that's pretty much because he didn't get driven every other scene.

I go for Batman 1989

Batman the Movie 1966, absolutely

I do really like Superman & the Mole Men 1951, but its effects are really bad. Superman the Movie 1978 is fun and overflowing with charm, plus a great cast, but I've never 100% loved the script, and BATMAN 1989 has an awesome Bruce and maybe the best production design of ALL TIME from Anton Furst, but suffers from a mixture of Burton seeming to like Joker more than Batman, and also making a lot of decisions with Joker that I truly just don't like very much, haha 😅

Whereas Batman the Movie 1966 is basically perfect!

Never seen Swamp Thing. Need to do so. Steel is underrated honestly, but it's not shocking that it's nobody's favorite so far!

Simon Eichorn is just straight up incorrect