Alright here we go.
First, what I liked. Also, spoilers. Please read it. Please.
I love how it focuses on the detective side of Batman, while still managing to give a lot of good action when it needs too.
Tim Sale's art is stunning, some of the best I've seen, and I loved the April Fool's Day cover. The fact it doesn't reveal who holiday is-well, they kind of do-makes it a lot better. Christmas would have to be my favorite part, the Joker's design is great, too. Harvey Dent being 2-Face was surprising because I didn't know who 2-Face's identity was. Honestly every part with Harvey was a blast. Batman's costume is great.
Now the things I didn't like.
It can be very slow at some points, a little too slow. But only in like 2 parts so doesn't really matter.
Maybe could have been shorter but other than that GREAT comic.
Low 10/10 but still a 10/10.