- Robin Lord Taylor as The Penguin
- Camren Bicondova as Selina Kyle
- Nathan Darrow as Mister Freeze
- Ben McKenzie as James Gordon
- Donal Logue as Harvey Bullock
- Gotham Stories takes place between "Worse Than a Crime" and Wrath of the Villains: Mr. Freeze".
- Instead of being released separately, Chapter 5 was merged with the other episodes in the compiled video released by Gotham's official YouTube channel.