FANDOM

A FANDOM user
  Loading editor
  • I took the liberty to remove gen:Lock 13 because ReadDC and Comixology list it releasing on March 18. Hope you don't mind.

    Also I think it's better to ask the admins regarding the mentioning of collections and digital comics in the note as a precaution. Tupka hid the entire list, including the collections that did release physically.

      Loading editor
    • I certainly do not mind you correcting me for being wrong: in fact, thanks a lot! I was doing the same as you just did: making the note accurate. It is not true that "DC didn't release any digital or physical comics today", so I don't know why we would want to say that on our front page.

        Loading editor
    • This reply has been removed
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • Why did you add back characters who have little to no role in JLA Vol 1 1 asides from being mentioned, as featured or supporting characters? DO they play a starring/featured role? Or a supporting role in any manner? Adding mentioned-only characters is contradictory to "featured" or "supporting cast"'s defintion unless they atleast have a major behind the scenes role, even if they're members of a starring or supporting team.

      Loading editor
    Tupka217
    Tupka217 closed this thread because:
    Enough. Take a break.
    17:25, March 22, 2020
    • View all 9 replies
    • It's you who's started it and is insistent on what he wants. Besides you can't edit war with yourself, and I reverted my self-revert after 24 hours.

      How is "the guidelines don't say [x]" a good response? You're simply sayingg that because it doesn't explicitly say that team members can't be listed as featured or supporting, you'll organize it however you want.

      But I showed you specifically that it says only characters playing an actual major role can be included as featured or supported characters.

      And no I don't confuse anyone by removing those team members. Because you can simply click it and go to that character's page, read the infobox or read another issue where they are a member.

        Loading editor
    • And at least I stop reverting after one or two reverts and don't try to endlessly revert if it's clear it'll result in an endless edit-war.

        Loading editor
  • So as to avoid any dispute in advance, the textless cover guidelines state that the description field for textless covers needs to be filled with the characters shown in the cover, not the volume and issue number of the comic. See Help:Textless Cover Images#Description.

      Loading editor
  • Why the hell are you edit-warring me over alphabetical order? Help:Comic Template#Template:A shows how we should organize characters. K comes before M in English alphabetical order. It's K-L-M not M-L-K.

    So Kraww should be listed before Mark, otherwise the list will be chaotically organized.

      Loading editor
    Tupka217
    Tupka217 closed this thread because:
    18:38, March 11, 2020
    • View all 16 replies
    • Here's an example, listing of members Parliament of Bangladesh, ypu'll see it's organized by first name, middle name and surname: https://amarmp.com/mpsearch

      Oh and I've visited the country and many other parts of Asia. You are baselessly arguing over this matter and baselessly accusing me of "making things up".

      Please self-revert. I've proven your claim of family name always being used to organize names as wrong. And the admin most of all already told you that the first letter after a pipe needs to be used.

        Loading editor
    • Okay, this has been fun. Walk away, people.

        Loading editor
  • Is Spanner's Galaxy set in New Earth? I always assumed it was in its own continuity.

      Loading editor
    • View all 10 replies
    • If I was indexing it, I would link the appearances with Spanner's Galaxy as the universe. As for the Vibe appearance, you could link it to the original and leave a note though I doubt there will ever be a follow-up on it.

        Loading editor
    • Boss. Thanks for your time and judgement.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • Shouldnt we keep Alfred as live for now, since his death wasnt very well shown? We never even saw his face.

      Loading editor
  • Why'd you undo the edit? That line doesn't do anything.

      Loading editor
    • Because an emdash means "nothing" but a hyphen doesn't mean that.

        Loading editor
    • A hyphen adds it to the last issues category list. Unless we don't do that anymore it seems fit to add it. I guess it doesn't matter much tho.

        Loading editor
    • Wow, it does--good eye, Oak. But it does *not* add it to [month] last issues. Hm. Maybe a bug to raise? Thanks for posting here.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • I think you went kind of overboard on the links in galleries. For example, do we really need to see also the Green Arrow’s Chili gallery from the Dark Knight Returns Ollie gallery? My personal opinion is that those links would be limited to probably only disambig and maybe a couple other places I’m not thinking of.

      Loading editor
    • On the one hand, it's definitely a decent amount of links. On the other, it's just a gallery, so it's not like it distracts from a bunch of text... Maybe a navbox situation that allows you to navigate them? Seems to me like for a page like a New Earth gallery, it's worth having links "horizontally" to other relevant New Earth topics (e.g. between Dinah Drake (New Earth)/Gallery and Justice League of America/Gallery) and "vertically" to different realities of the same character (e.g. Oliver Queen (Prime Earth)/Gallery) but links that are "diagonal" across them are lower value. In the case of galleries for things or concepts like his chili or the Arrowcar, those galleries themselves are for multiple realities. Does that make sense?

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • I particularly like the names which they adopted in Justice League of America Vol 1 200, but the Appellaxians aren't individualy named in Post-Crisis.

      Loading editor
    • Sure--you could just rename them {{A|[[Golden Roc (Earth-One)|golden eagle monster]]}} if you think that's better but I frankly don't think it's an improvement. Do you have a better suggestion?

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  •   Loading editor
See archived talk page
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.