FANDOM


  • 100% True? (Volume 1) originally had a "Winter 1996" start and "Summer 1996" end but this rendered as "December 1996" for the start date and "June 1996" for the end. Any idea how to reconcile this?

      Loading editor
    • This was a bit of an awkward work-around for a general formatting and categorization problem - which is, in simple terms, that seasons don't mesh well with the math being used in our back-end.

      We compromised on Winter/Summer corresponding to Dec/June - even though that's not always the case. Ideally, we'd have a way to show "Winter" and "Summer", but categorize as the actual pull-month. But, obviously, that date isn't always readily available - especially with older series/issues, nor is it consistent.

      Based on the information they have at comics.org, the first issue came out on June 12th - which according to our standard would technically give it a start-month of August, while the second came out on November 20th - which corresponds to a start month of January.

        Loading editor
    • I've just stumbled across this very issue with Batman Chronicles Vol 1 (1995) which is is published as winter, spring, summer, fall. But the assumption that winter = December causes the publication dates to seem very erratic when you page through them in the DC database as winter often ought to mean January. This is pretty unfortunate as this is exactly the sort of circumstance when you are going to go to the database to get a better publication date - namely when there isn't a proper month on the comic. I was putting a box in order and this caused me quite a bit of puzzlement till I figured out what was going on.

        Loading editor
    • Can we not make a solution with a piped value that displays X but categorizes Y?

        Loading editor
    • Lua doesn't like pipes. Every time you think you've solved a problem, you've created two more.

        Loading editor
    • Then may be to use templates like {winter} that output some value. Or have a new field that just has a display date and a second for a categorization date.

        Loading editor
    • Is there a reason that I'm not understanding that a comic published as 'winter 96' isn't just stored and displayed as 'winter 96'? As soon as you start trying to do an automatic transform on that to a month then you're relying on your code's understanding of winter being the same as the publisher's. With the result that the comic just ends up 11 months out of synch half the time.

        Loading editor
    • Because there's also math attached to it to calculate the street date, -2 months. Which relies on there being a number, or a name-to-number.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.